1. David Hernandez (Midnight Hour by Wilson Pickett) - Amazing.
2. Chikezie (More Today than Yesterday by Stevie Wonder)- Shakey vocals.
3. David Cook (Happy Together by The Turtles) - Decent vocal, decent performance.
4. Jason Yeager (Moonriver by Andy Williams) - One of better vocals but still not brilliant.
5. Robbie Carrico (One is the Loneliest Number by Harry Nilsson) - Good vocal, love the song choice.
6. David Archuleta (Shop Around by The Miracles) - Potentially great but vocal was a shaky.
7. Danny Noriega (Jailhouse Rock by Elvis Prestley) - Really average. Not a great song for him.
8. Luke Menard (Everybody's Talkin by Harry Nilsson) - Horrible. Very weak performance.
9. Colton Berry (Suspicious Minds by Elvis Presley) - OK but nothing special.
10. Garrett Haley (Breaking Up is Hard To Do by Neil Sedaka) - Weak and insipid.
11. Jason Castro (Daydream by Lovin' Spoonful) - Love his voice and personality.
12. Michael Johns (Light The Fire by The Doors) - It was just ok.